Planet Z Commentary: Breaking the silence of ‘climate hushing’

How political interests, economic systems, and the fear of speaking out have quieted climate conversations — and why it’s time to amplify.

Art by Harper Horvath

Planet Z: Voices of Youth for a Sustainable Future is a Gen Z–created series sharing unfiltered perspectives on climate change — from eco-anxiety and grief to the urgency, creativity, and resolve shaping their generation. Support for this series is provided by Consumers Energy.

I want people to talk about the Earth more. Our voices come from the Earth and our lips too and our brains we use to think. I want people to think about the Earth more. Our voices come from the Earth and our lips too and our brains we use to think and our hearts we use to beat. I want people to love about the Earth more. Our voices come from the Earth and our lips too and our brains we use to think and our hearts we use to beat and our lungs we use to breathe. I want people to breathe about the Earth more. Without her, there is no us. No life. Without her, without us, there is nothing to hush. 

Allow me to fill you in: Behind much of the chaos shaping our world today is a common thread: the climate crisis and global energy transition. Despite their far-reaching consequences, these forces often go unrecognized and undiscussed. 

The signs are all around us, woven into our everyday lives. We feel it at the gas pump and when our electricity bills arrive. We see our military invade another oil-rich country. And when a record-breaking winter storm leaves more than a million Americans without power, the vulnerabilities of our aging electrical grid become impossible to ignore. Yet despite how frequently these issues affect our lives, the larger conversation about climate change and energy often remains overlooked. 

We watch as the very organizations responsible for protecting our environment, like the Environmental Protection Agency, put corporate interests ahead of public well-being. We witness the immense influence of fossil fuel money in politics, exposing corruption and accountability concerns at every level of government. 

And yet, the silence surrounding climate change persists. 

This silence has a name: “climate hushing.” It describes the deliberate avoidance of climate-related conversations out of concern that addressing the issue could come at a political cost. However, to cease the freefall we find our country in, we must speak up honestly about climate and energy. 

Art by Jade Breznau

America has been experiencing climate hushing on a more dramatic scale since the start of Trump’s administration. It just so happens that he has surrounded himself with the right people to execute his anti-climate agenda. In all cases, climate hushing floods in when room for climate conversation is eliminated. 

With Trump’s eagerness to dismantle the climate protections we had set in place, the outlets for climate education and conversation were crushed, putting the health of our planet at a much greater risk. On President Trump’s first day of the first year of his second term, he declared an unnecessary “national energy emergency” to open up more areas to oil and gas exploration, which is exactly what followed. 

The administration has maximized oil and gas development in Alaska, reversing restrictions on the 23-million-acre National Petroleum Reserve-Alaska and reopening the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge for drilling. He has signed a series of executive orders reviving a dying coal industry, while contradicting global trends, nearly 60 countries have drastically scaled back their plans for building coal-fired power plants since the Paris Agreement was passed in 2015. Aside from being the dirtiest type of fossil fuel, coal is widely seen as an uncompetitive and unsuitable energy source, costing more than renewables like wind and solar.

All of this to say the facts are obvious: Our country is not taking climate change seriously enough and is settling in, too comfortable with climate hushing. And if our government’s decisions from 2025 don’t encourage more people to be climate amplifiers, I’m not sure what will. 

But this climate hushing behavior has been around for a long time in American politics. 

Let’s take it back a few decades. In the early ’90s we had the first United Nations agreement around climate (Rio Earth Summit, 1992) happening at the same moment George W. Bush was negotiating the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA), which would open up free markets, breaking down tariffs, and more. In 1995, we had the WTO (World Trade Organization). 

“So, we have these countervailing forces happening at the same time. Right as we have to really curb GHG (greenhouse gases), we’re opening up global trade, accelerating it with very few provisions of how to protect the environment or labor,” says Bart Elmore, an environmental historian, speaking with Planet Z on the matter.

Elmore works at Ohio State University and has a passion for understanding how our material world interacts with the natural world. 

Government officials were “…deliberately trying to sow doubt about the science that was being delivered at that time, so clearly showing from ice cores to air monitoring systems in Hawaii that we had this really big problem of GHG.” 

When science revealed to the U.S. how serious climate change was, there was the simultaneous creation of international agreements that fundamentally accelerated the climate crisis. This is an act of climate hushing by the government, where there should have been action to amplify the significance of the climate crisis. 

You see, in a capitalist society, acting on behalf of climate change is not believed to grow your dollars, even though in reality, focusing on sustainability (closed systems, renewables, less waste, healthier land for carbon sequestration, etc.) dramatically brings down prices and the risks brought to the environment. So, if it’s a win/win situation, why aren’t we acting on it? 

My hypothesis: money. Money is the universal driving factor, and systems take a lot of work to change – reconstructing current policies and systems would be taking away from the people and corporations who are financially benefiting from them. 

We’ve gotten to a point where it’s considered normal, expected even, for these powerful corporations to face no repercussions from their contributions to the climate crisis. They live behind the silver screen while we purchase overpriced tickets to see their sh#@* movies. But it doesn’t have to be that way. What if these thoughts were being brought to the podium? What if climate hushing disappeared, giving rise to national and global climate conversations? 

No one wants to watch their home collapse into the ocean, get washed away by a hurricane or mudslide, or get bought out for the next data center. So let’s get to talking about it! 

Art by Safia Abiad 

Be a climate amplifier

It’s no one’s fault that they are uninformed, but if you have the privilege to be knowledgeable about climate issues, be a climate amplifier. Collectivism is a key defender against climate collapse and that can only happen when we take from The Lorax and speak for the trees. Let’s talk about the benefits of climate amplifying. Let’s talk about clinging to outdated systems for the upkeep of our homes, when climate-ready adaptations save households money in the long run. Educate your communities that proper insulation, renewable energy, solar panel roofing, healthy soil, etc. are investments in the planet as well as our homes, wallets, and futures. 

These solutions aren’t a far-off fantasy; they’re already within reach. A more sustainable, affordable, and climate-resilient future is on the horizon only if we show we want it.

If you want to see change, be a climate amplifier. If you want your children to live a successful life, be a climate amplifier. If you want to end the sixth extinction, be a climate amplifier. If you love the world, be a climate amplifier. If you hate hate, be a climate amplifier. If you love love, be a climate amplifier. 

The future isn’t going to build itself. It’s time we stop hushing and start talking. 

Artists’s statements

My name is Safia Abiad. I’m a junior majoring in aerospace engineering. I used acrylic paint and a finger-painting technique for the lavender. Then I dripped red, white, and black acrylic paint over the top to create a stark contrast. 
I’m Jade Breznau and I like colors. 

Author

Harper Horvath represents her generation in the climate crisis as an award-winning climate activist, youth organizer, and poet. She is the project editor for Planet Z and a chemistry lab technician in the Bertman lab at Western Michigan University, where she studies biology, sustainability, and journalism. Her favorite book is "Perfume" by Patrick Süskind, her favorite song is "Gardenhead/Leave Me Alone" by Neutral Milk Hotel, and her favorite tree is a Redwood.

Our Sponsors

Gilmore Foundation

Our Media Partners

Battle Creek Community Foundation
BINDA Foundation
Southwest Journalism Media Collaborative
Southwest Michigan First
Consumers Energy
WK Kellogg Foundation logo

Don't miss out!

Everything Southwest Michigan, in your inbox every week.

Close the CTA

Already a subscriber? Enter your email to hide this popup in the future.